The short version
- What it is: someone who can see the names people search for registers the promising ones first, then sells them back, or holds them so you can only buy them from one place.
- Why it’s among the worst: most patterns here work on you at the checkout or after it. This one uses the search itself, before you’ve agreed to anything.
- How common it is: hard to prove, and most “stolen” names turn out to be coincidence. But in 2008 a large US registrar openly held every available name searched on its site for four days.
- How to beat it: if you want a name and it’s free, register it then and there, at the registrar you’d buy from anyway. Don’t shop it around lookup sites.
- At Chill Domains: we never register or hold a name you searched, and we don’t sell or share what people search.
What does it look like?
- 1The search is the leak. Typing a name into a box tells whoever runs it, and anyone they pass it to, that a real person wants that exact name.
- 2Days later the name is taken and listed for sale, at a price set by how much they think you want it.
- 3The tell: the name was registered minutes after you looked. A public WHOIS or RDAP lookup on a .com shows the creation date.
How could anyone see what I searched?
A domain search isn’t private by nature. In 2007, ICANN’s Security and Stability Advisory Committee (SSAC) listed the places a searched name passes through, and anyone at any of them could in principle collect it:
- The site you search on, whether it’s a registrar, a reseller, or a free “is it available?” lookup site.
- The registrar and the registry behind it, which answer the availability check.
- “Name spinners”: when a name is taken, many sites check the same word in other endings to suggest alternatives, so one search becomes several.
- Browser add-ons and toolbars that can see what you type, and the DNS servers your computer asks about a name.
Most of these see searches because they have to, to answer them. The pattern is what someone does next.
Has it really happened?
Proof is hard to come by. SSAC asked people who believed they’d been front-run to send in the details, and in February 2008 it reported back: for every complaint it could check, it found another plausible explanation, such as coincidence, a name that had been registered before, or domain tasting (below). It said that didn’t prove front running never happens; it just had no smoking gun.
The clearest case is one a registrar defended in public. In January 2008, a large US registrar began holding every available name searched on its own site for up to four days. During those four days you could still register it, but only there. If nobody bought it, the name went back on general sale. The company said it was protecting customers from front running. Critics said it simply locked people in. Either way, it showed that the search itself was being used.
Why was it cheap to do?
For years, a .com or other gTLD could be registered and returned within five days for a full refund, under a rule called the Add Grace Period. That made it nearly free to grab names in bulk, see which ones drew visitors, and hand the rest back: domain tasting. In 2008 ICANN started charging for returns above a small allowance, and its Add Grace Period Limits Policy took effect for .com, .net and .org on 1 April 2009. ICANN reported a 99.7% drop in grace-period returns between June 2008 and April 2009. Holding a searched name now costs the full registration fee, which makes front running less tempting. It doesn’t make it impossible.
Why is it among the worst patterns?
Most dark patterns on this site push you at the point of sale: a pre-ticked box, a hidden renewal, a countdown. You can still say no. Front running happens before you’ve bought anything or agreed to anything, and it uses the one thing you have to tell a seller, which is the name you want. In 2007 SSAC recorded the argument that “spying” on what a customer searches is unethical and breaks the trust between customer and registrar. We agree.
It might just be bad luck
Before deciding you’ve been front-run, check the simple explanations:
- Someone else had the same idea. Short words, trending phrases and obvious business names get registered every day.
- The name was never really free. It may have been registered earlier and not yet showing in a lookup, or it was an expiring name that someone caught when it dropped. Catching expired names at auction is a normal, open business.
- The dates don’t match. Look up the name’s creation date. If it was registered weeks before your search, your search didn’t cause it.
How do I search without giving myself away?
- Decide, then search. If the name matters to you and it’s free, register it in the same sitting. A year of a domain costs far less than buying it back.
- Search where you’d buy. Use the registrar you trust, not five free lookup sites. Every extra site is one more party that knows.
- Be wary of unknown lookup sites and browser add-ons that offer domain ideas or “availability checks”, especially ones that won’t say who runs them.
- Don’t announce first. Register the name before you post the new brand, product or event anywhere public.
- If you think it happened, write down when and where you searched, then look up the name’s creation date and registrar. Our toolbox has a free WHOIS lookup. Send what you find to the site you searched on and ask for an explanation in writing.
A .com.au is a harder target, because whoever registers it has to meet auDA’s eligibility rules, such as an Australian business with a link to the name. Our guide Is auDA changing who can register a .com.au? explains the rules and what may change. Global endings like .com have no such rules.
What does the law say?
No law here is aimed at it directly, and SSAC noted in 2007 that ICANN’s agreements with registrars and registries didn’t expressly forbid watching availability checks. But if a business tells you it doesn’t use your searches and then does, that can be misleading conduct under the Australian Consumer Law. And collecting what you type through software you didn’t knowingly install is a different matter again.
What does Chill Domains do instead?
At Chill Domains. When you search, the name goes from our site to our registrar, Synergy Wholesale, which asks the registry whether it’s free. If it’s taken, we check the same name in up to six other endings so we can suggest one. That’s where it stops. We never register or hold a name until someone has paid for it, so a name you search and don’t buy stays free for anyone, at any registrar. We don’t sell or share searches, and we keep the names out of our Google Analytics. Our server and registrar-connection logs record lookups, as any site’s logs do, and we use them only to fix faults.
Questions people ask
I searched for a domain and now someone else has registered it. Was I front-run?
Is it safe to check whether a domain name is available?
Can a registrar hold a name I searched so I can only buy it from them?
Sources
- SAC 022: SSAC Advisory on Domain Name Front Running (ICANN Security and Stability Advisory Committee, October 2007): the definition, and where a searched name can be seen.
- SAC 024: Report on Domain Name Front Running (SSAC, February 2008): what it found when it checked the complaints.
- The Register, 10 January 2008: the registrar that held searched names for four days, and its explanation.
- The End of Domain Tasting (ICANN status report on the Add Grace Period measures, August 2009).
- Our promises and the code behind our domain search: our own practice, as at 14 November 2026.
General information, not legal advice. We sell domains, so read this as a seller’s view.
Keep reading
- Dark patterns in the domain business: every pattern we’ve written up, and the case files.
- Fake urgency and scarcity: the opposite trick, a hurry that isn’t real.
- Making it hard to leave: locks and fees that keep a name where it is.
- Registry, registrar, reseller: who handles your search, and your domain.
