What did the ad say?
The ad appeared in a ChatGPT answer, under a line from ChatGPT offering “a domain search and registration option”. Its promise is about the price you’ll pay after the first year:
That’s a good thing to promise. The renewal price is the one you pay every year after the first, so it matters more than the first-year price. Here’s how the search page shows it.
The short answer
Free for the first year, but only with an annual plan from the same provider, and only for the first year. The .com showed $0.00 a year beside a crossed-out $9.90. Its renewal price, AU$44.00, only appeared when we hovered over the small info icon next to “Free for 1 year”.
- Free with a plan. The free year needs “any annual plan”.
- A crossed-out price that isn’t the renewal. $9.90 crossed out; $44.00 to renew, about 4.4 times as much.
- The renewal price behind an icon. It’s on the search page, but you have to hover the icon (or tap it on a phone) to see it.
Chill Domains sells domains, so we have an interest here. We haven’t named the provider, and we’ve removed its name and logo from the screenshots. We searched without signing in, from Australia. The search page doesn’t say whether its prices include GST, so we quote them exactly as shown. Its prices may have changed since 13 November 2026.
What does the .com renew at?
AU$44.00. The search shows the .com at $0.00 a year, with $9.90 crossed out above “Free for 1 year”. Hover over the info icon and a box opens:
So the renewal price is on the page before you pay. It just isn’t next to the price, and it’s about 4.4 times the crossed-out figure that is.
Is a renewal price behind an icon a dark pattern?
Yes. It’s the price you’ll pay every year after the first, and it’s the one price on the page you have to go looking for. The numbers in plain sight are $0.00 and a crossed-out $9.90. The $44.00 only appears if you hover over a small icon. On a phone there’s nothing to hover: you’d have to know to tap it. Show the small numbers, tuck the big one away: that’s the pattern.
The crossed-out $9.90 makes it worse. A crossed-out price says “this is what it normally costs”. From the second year, this .com normally costs $44.00.
And the ad promised “first-year and renewal prices, shown upfront”. A price you only see if you hover over an icon isn’t shown upfront. Many people buying their first domain won’t know to look for it. If the renewal is the price that matters, it belongs next to the price, in the same size type.
Same words, different renewal: the Slim Shady problem
That ad line sounded familiar. Our home page says “with the renewal price up front”, and has since September 2026. We’re not saying anyone copied anyone. Plenty of providers talk about renewal prices now, and that’s good news.
But think of Eminem’s “The Real Slim Shady”: a room full of people dressed like him, and only one of them is him. Sounding like the real thing isn’t the same as being it. Theirs is a free first year, a crossed-out $9.90, and a $44.00 renewal you have to hover to find. Ours is a .com at $28 a year inc GST, printed on the same line as year one, renewing at $28.
Which dark patterns does this search show?
Four, three of them on our list. None of them is unique to this provider, and a free first year with a plan can be a fair deal if you want the plan anyway. But you can only judge the deal with the renewal price in front of you.
- The renewal price out of sight. The price you pay every year after the first only shows when you hover over an icon.
- Intro pricing. $0.00 for year one, then $44.00.
- A discount against the seller’s own price. The crossed-out $9.90 is the seller’s own figure, and it isn’t the price you renew at.
- Free, with conditions. The free year comes with an annual plan, and the domain then renews on its own price.
What does a .com cost at Chill Domains?
$28 a year inc GST, to register and to renew.
At Chill Domains. A .com is $28 a year inc GST, and it renews at the same list price new customers pay that day. We don’t show crossed-out prices, and there’s no third number to hover for: the price on the page is the price every year. Our cart shows the total, inc GST, before you sign in or create anything. The rest of our promises are on how it works.
Questions people ask
Is a free domain with a website plan a scam?
Is the crossed-out price what I’ll pay next year?
Where do I find a domain’s renewal price?
Sources
- The ad and the search itself: our screenshots of another provider’s ad in ChatGPT and its domain search for jackscooldomain, taken on 13 November 2026 without signing in, shown above with the provider’s name and logo removed. Every price and quotation about that provider comes from them.
- Chill Domains pricing and our promises: our own prices and terms, as at 13 November 2026.
General information, not financial or legal advice. Prices are as at the dates shown; check the page in front of you.
Keep reading
- Dark patterns in the domain business: the rest of the patterns, and what we do instead.
- Intro pricing: the pattern guide, with how to spot it.
- Case file 1: the $0.01 domain and its cart and case file 2: the $0.05 domain and its checkout.
- Jack’s Renewal Run: the same hoops, as a game.
